Miracles, February 6, 2001

As Reviewed by Michele Blackburn

As Reviewed by Yali


By Michele Blackburn

Aliens, Miracles, and relationships. These were the three main topics of this show.

Aliens. Wasn't Tiner cute at the computer? He's getting just as wild about Aliens as Bud is and it looked later on in the show like the Admiral was wondering if there really was signs of alien life out there.

Miracles. Gerald McRaney did a fabulous job portraying the Seargent Major. He was very convincing as he told the court about how he found his wife because of something a dead padre showed him. Even though he was found guilty, I believe that he really was innocent of the crime and that the real attackers are out there somewhere, but the way TPTB left it the storyline could continue in the next few months or next season.

Relationships. I thought Harm and Renée were cute on Sunday morning at his house. They seemed like husband and wife. Renée laying across Harm's lap. Both of them reading the paper. Then when Mac and Renée made that date (well actually Renée did) but at least she's trying to get along with Mac. I loved the scene with Harm and Mic outside Headquarters when Mic told him that they were going on a double date. Harm's reaction was priceless. Then the date itself. Boy, was there a lot of tension in that room. Renée just wanted to get to know Mac and Mic a little better, Harm and Mac kept talking about old times on the sub and when Harm thought he saw his father (Silent Service, Ghost Ship) and Mic, well, Mic was just jealous. I felt sorry for Harm as he watched Mic and Mac together. This was one show where I didn't care for Mic too much and I'm a huge Mic fan. Then we have the scene with Renée and Harm where she's trying to get Harm to admit if there relationship is going anywhere. Again, Harm acts completely clueless.

Speaking of relationships, Karri Turner and Patrick Labyorteaux are great together as husband and wife. I felt like crying as Bud asked the Priest why his daughter had to die while others lived. They also gave an emotional performance as they put Sarah's things away. Blankets, stuffed animals and an engraved baby book. BTW, isn't Karri Turner's new haircut really cute?

Guest Star: Gerald McRaney (Major Dad, Promise Land)
Quotes of the week:

"If you don't go to church on Sunday morning they send a Priest to you---Renée to Harm

"Mrs. Rabb?"
"No, that would be his mother."--Renée to the priest

"That's so couplish."--Mic to Mac

"It's a miracle anyone would want to be with Brumby."---Harm to Renée


By Yali

Pater Nostrum, please forgive Donald Bellisario and his TV screenwriters, for they do not know what they have just did to this episode. Flesh is weak, and human inspiration is moody.

Tonight's episode had all the qualities to be a tour de force one- action, angst, suspense and three storylines interweaved with the same leitmotif: questioning faith. Faith in the supernatural (Tiner with the SETI screensaver [as a Puerto Rican, I feel proud that the Arecibo Radiotelescope, angular stone in the SETI project, was mentioned in the episode]), faith in God (the canonization of the Marine chaplain, Bud's revealed anger against Him for the death of Baby Sarah), faith in having a future together with the one you love (Mac and Mic, Renée). They just did it fine, until… Oh, Lord, have mercy.

Sergeant-Major Krohn claims the Marine chaplain of his Vietnam division, fallen in action, appeared to him to lead him to where his wife was agonizing, victim of an alleged carjacker. Civilian police arrest him as a prime suspect, but Harm convinces the detective that Navy JAG has jurisdiction over the case because of the suspect's military high rank. Adm. Chegwidden appoints Bud and Harm as prosecutor and defendant, respectively. Charges against Sergeant-Major Krohn are attempted murder and domestic violence, since he has a previous record of it.

The trial against Sergeant-Major Krohn was bifurcated into the criminal part and the religious part, concentrated on demonstrating the high probability of the miracle claimed by the accused, and its direct relation to the criminal case. Mrs. Krohn recovers, but she's unable to testify in court; the police delivers a written deposition of her accounts, exculpating her husband (Harm has it on his file). Father O'Rourke, an American delegate at the Vatican department that verifies sainthood claims from across the world, is contacted by the supporters of the chaplain's canonization to review this case. He contacts Harm and requests permission to attend the trial. Eventually, he's called as a defense witness. Harm discovers how little information he has on the subject, and decides to read more about it.

Tiner get involved in the SETI project and installs the experimental screensaver on the Admiral's PC. The Admiral doesn't remember giving his consent to it but he allows it (after all, it's just a screensaver, no viruses allowed). Tiner gets excited when he perceives what it seems to be a tracking signal.

Renée shows up at JAG with tickets for a pub concert of a band she's making the music video, and practically forces Mac to go with Mic, and Harm is dragged along. He gets to know about it when Mic reminds him of Friday's "double date". Ah, his face at the pub. He simply wanted to be somewhere else. His boredom shows at the exact moment Mic is flirting with his fiancée and talks about their wedding. Renée looks at him and is disappointed. This scene can be interpreted in two ways. Shipper- Harm is definitely jealous and Renée notices. Non-shipper- Harm is bored, he can't stand PDA's (Public Displays of Affection) and Renée feels bad for dragging him there, because he doesn't feel comfortable. It all depends on your belief.

One thing is for sure: Mac enjoys being in Mic's company.

TPTB did their assignment on how a canonization process is. A case must be opened at the Vatican, proper research must be done, evidence has to be disclosed and cross-examined, and a special jury must decide if the candidate proposed has all the qualities for being considered a saint. If so, the correct steps in reaching sainthood are: Venerable (the candidate is considered a role model for his/her heroic Christian virtues), Blessed (devotees can pray to him/her after a miracle is proved to be done by his/her intervention), and Saint (another miracle must have been done after being declared Blessed). A special investigator, like Father O'Rourke, is appointed to investigate the veracity of those miracles and claims. This process can take years, even centuries. Take for example Saint Joan of Arc, a XIII-century French saint, canonized in the 1920's. But there is the case of Saint Maria Goretti, declared Blessed in 1947 and canonized in 1950. It all depends on how things develop. Also, Venerables and Blesseds can remain so for years to come.

There are military officers among the saints; for example, Saint Ignatius of Loyola, and Saint George, England's patron saint. Saint Barbara is the patroness of soldiers worldwide. And yes, there is a Catholic Encyclopedia and a Book of Saints, the original one at the Vatican.

What Tiner thinks is an extraterrestrial signal is really a radio transmission from a "deceased" pulsar from beyond space, several millions of years late. However, it doesn't diminishes his hopes in finding extraterrestrial life, and he retires. Adm. Chegwidden smiles comprehensively. Deep inside, maybe he wants it to be true…

At the pub, while waiting for The Roches, Harm and Mac talks about the case. Mic seems to understand what they're talking about, while Renée is wandering somewhere else. Later, she comments to Harm that the union of two totally different people like Mic and Mac seems like a miracle. Harm says that the real miracle is that actually someone can feel for Mic. Then, Harm receives a call requesting his presence for the verdict. From Renée's last comment after Harm leaves, we can infer that things are not well in that relation, and only a miracle can fix it.

Before it, still at the pub, Mac points to Harm that his client's experience might been real. After all, he always had faith in seeing his father alive, and he sensed his presence many times. He sees some light in that remark, and it showed on his defense strategy. His closing argumentation was just brilliant. I wanted to jump into the screen to kiss him. The courtroom scenes were excellent.

Bud questions Father O'Rourke and God for Baby Sarah's death. He never ventilated it in consideration to Harriet, but after she asked him to help her gather all the unopened gifts and items, he lets it go out. It influenced his interrogatory and cross-examining during the trial. He sounded and acted very cynical, a bit more of how a prosecutor must be, n my opinion. He was getting personal, and Harm was right in raising objections. He won the case, but it didn't bring him any peace.

Sergeant-Major Krohn was declared guilty from all the charges, but there wasn't any punishment! He went directly to jail, without any announce on forfeit payment, separation of the charge, years sentenced and the like. Harm opened his eyes and I yelled on the other side of the tube. What kind of sentence was it? But his client is calmed. His faith has sustained him during the trial, and it will be like that now. Even when a surprise witness, retired officer Randy Hamill, comes along to impugn the sainthood claims and the incident on the battlefield, his faith and beliefs didn't shatter. Harm was able to crumble the witness' deposition with facts and wit, bringing back faith to those who needed it most- surprisingly, Father O'Rourke, who doubted of the previous process after listening to Mr. Hamill.

Father O'Rourke thanks Harm for helping him on his own investigation, and for giving a boost to his faith. He assures him that the process will continue. Harm asks him when it will be concluded. -"Call me in a hundred years. That long it takes."- He exits.

Close up to Harm. Closing credits.

That's all?!

The screenwriters' heresy began when Bud's anger at God wasn't resolved. His closing argumentation at the trial made him sound as if he was disappointed with life for it being cruel to he and Harriet. He never talked about it with anyone after his first "crisis" on court. Then, it continued with that crappy sentence. My Criminal Procedures professor, who is also a judge, would faint if she hears something like that. D.C. Police didn't have a clue on Mrs. Krohn's carjacking, not even the slightest one. When did the investigation end? And the abrupt closing scene was ad nauseam. I loved Harm's close up, but I also expected a convincing ending, not such a slap on the face.

It has to be one of two- writers' muse took a long day off and didn't return on time to finish the script, or they ceded to some temptation that wretched any good and worthy idea they had for it. Anyway, they committed a serious offense against the intelligence and expectations of us loyal viewers. What did we do to deserve such mutilated ending?

However, last thing we lose is faith. We can only hope that TPTB gives us an episode the next week enough for us to forgive them for what happened today. To err is human, but don't overdo it.

Amen.


previous episode review//next episode review